Put in Bay Hotels With Pool: What Bay Lodging Offers Guests

Not every hotel on the island has real pool access, so if you're specifically searching for put in bay hotels with pool amenities, it's worth knowing exactly what's included before you book. Bay Lodging has an indoor/outdoor pool on-site, along with a hot tub and a poolside bar, making it one of the more complete options for guests who want to relax without leaving the property.

Put-in-Bay attracts close to a million visitors a year, and while most people come for the bars, live music, and restaurants on Delaware Street, a lot of that same crowd also wants somewhere to unwind during the day — especially in the summer heat. That's where Bay Lodging's pool setup becomes a real differentiator among put in bay hotels with pool listings. The pool is 3 to 5 feet deep, indoor/outdoor, and paired with a hot tub, giving guests flexibility depending on the weather or time of day.

Right next to the pool is SJ's Hideaway Bar, a fully stocked outdoor bar that lets guests grab a drink without walking downtown. Pool hours run 8:00 AM to 10:00 PM Sunday through Thursday, and until 11:00 PM on Fridays and Saturdays, though hours can shift with weather since the pool is seasonal.

Beyond the pool, Bay Lodging's location is part of what makes it stand out among put in bay hotels with pool access. The hotel sits in a quiet corner of downtown Put-in-Bay, close enough for a short walk, bike ride, or golf cart trip to the island's restaurants and nightlife, but far enough removed to actually get a good night's sleep.

Room options are built to match different group sizes. Single King rooms are popular for couples, Double Queen rooms (with ADA-accessible options) work for small families, and Triple Queen rooms sleep up to six adults. Standard amenities include a private bath, 40-inch TV with cable, free WiFi, mini-fridge, and hairdryer. For bigger groups, Bay Lodging offers suites with full kitchens — a two-bedroom, a two-bedroom split-level with a sleeping loft, and a three-bedroom option sleeping up to ten.

Golf cart rentals are available on-site as well, which matters if you're planning to explore beyond downtown. A 4-person cart costs $76 per day on weekdays and $87 on weekends, while a 6-person cart is $97 on weekdays and $109 on weekends. Ohio law treats golf carts as licensed vehicles, so drivers need to be 21 or older with a valid license, and standard traffic laws apply across the island.

Bay Lodging has been owned by the Alexander family since January 2020. Steve Alexander purchased the hotel just before the pandemic hit, and with his wife Tiffany and son Jac, has built the business around a family-first approach that's shaped how the property — including the pool area — is maintained and run for guests of all ages.

If pool access is a priority for your trip, it's worth confirming details directly, since amenities can vary a lot between listings that all show up under put in bay hotels with pool searches. Bay Lodging's pool, hot tub, and poolside bar are all on-site and included as part of the stay.